Faces of Gettysburg: The Unyielding Strength of Catharine Trostle

Faces of Gettysburg: The Unyielding Strength of Catharine Trostle

In the quaint town of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, Abraham Trostle, born between 1821 and 1822, faced a tumultuous life filled with personal battles and the harsh realities of the Civil War era. Let’s look dive into the captivating story of the Trostle family, shedding light on the remarkable strength of Catharine Trostle as she navigated through adversity, war, and the shifting dynamics of gender roles in the 19th century.

Early Family Life

Abraham, the second oldest of four children born to Peter and Sussanah Trostle, embraced farming like his parents. However, as mental illness and alcoholism took their toll on him, the responsibilities of running the Trostle family farm in Gettysburg increasingly fell on the capable shoulders of his wife, Catharine. The farm, acquired by Peter Trostle in 1839, played a pivotal role in the family’s life, symbolizing both their struggles and resilience.

Catharine, an extraordinary woman who defied traditional gender norms, married Abraham in 1844 and became the head of the household for decades. Their union resulted in eleven children, and despite Abraham’s challenges, Catharine managed the farm and navigated financial difficulties with determination. Neighbors in the close-knit Gettysburg community often provided support, reflecting the collaborative spirit of the time.

Family Troubles

The Trostle family faced public scrutiny when Abraham found infamy in local newspapers for assaulting Edward Ziegler in 1859. Despite financial stability, Abraham’s reputation suffered due to public drunkenness. His struggles with mental illness and alcoholism strained the family, leading to a shift in property ownership from Abraham to Catharine, challenging societal norms.

As the Battle of Gettysburg approached, the Trostles prepared for the impending conflict. Abraham’s deteriorating mental health and Catharine’s proactive efforts to protect their belongings showcased the family’s resilience in the face of uncertainty. When the battle erupted, the Trostle farm became a focal point, enduring the chaos and destruction of war.

War Comes Knocking

On July 2, 1863, the Trostle farm witnessed intense fighting. Union and Confederate forces clashed, and the Trostle family’s home transformed into a field hospital. Catharine, with her children, fled the escalating danger, leaving Abraham and George behind. The aftermath revealed the farm’s devastation, symbolizing the toll the war took on the Trostle family’s financial stability and Abraham’s mental health.

The Aftermath of War

Post-battle, Catharine faced the challenges of raising her children, restoring the farm, and dealing with Abraham’s declining mental health. The family’s miseries continued with Peter Trostle’s death in 1863, and the property officially passed to Catharine in 1865. Abraham’s relocation to the Harrisburg State Hospital further marginalized the family, reinforcing societal stigmas associated with mental illness.

In 1875, Catharine’s attempt to claim damages from the federal government for the farm’s destruction was denied. Despite facing financial setbacks and the tragic loss of valuables, the Trostle family, led by Catharine, displayed unwavering resilience. George eventually inherited the property, and the family’s decision to leave the cannonball hole in the barn wall stands as a testament to their enduring spirit in the face of adversity.

The Trostle family’s story is a poignant chapter in the history of Gettysburg, illustrating how one woman’s strength and determination overcame the challenges of war, societal norms, and personal hardship. Catharine Trostle’s legacy endures as a symbol of resilience and tenacity, an inspiring narrative of a woman who faced adversity head-on and emerged victorious.

There’s so much to learn and see in historic Gettysburg. Book your stay at the historic Tillie Pierce House Inn today!